Skip to content
Buy Access Panels

Brand comparison

Karp, Nystrom, Babcock-Davis and Elmdor access doors compared

Karp, Nystrom, Babcock-Davis and Elmdor are known for steel access doors for commercial work, including fire-rated models. Three of them also make a plastic access door. This page sets their plastic and drywall doors next to the Easy-Exs plastic panels and doors, from each maker's own pages and spec sheets, checked on November 15, 2026, and says when a steel door is the right call.

4 products

Products

  • Easy-Exs 8 × 8 in hinged access door, white plastic, open, with a shut-off valve behind the opening

    Easy-Exs · PAD0808

    8x8 in Plastic Drywall Access Panel with Hinged Door

    Rated 4.4 out of 5, 2,789 ratings online

    Maximum service opening 6.35 × 6.35 in · Overall 8 × 8 in

    USD $9.49 each

    • 10+ panels: $8.49 each
    • 80+ panels: $7.49 each
  • Easy-Exs 12 × 12 in hinged access door, white plastic, open, with a water meter behind the opening

    Easy-Exs · PAD1212

    12x12 in Plastic Drywall Access Panel with Hinged Door

    Rated 4.4 out of 5, 2,789 ratings online

    Maximum service opening 10.35 × 10.35 in (estimated) · Overall 12 × 12 in

    USD $13.99 each

    • 10+ panels: $10.99 each
    • 80+ panels: $9.49 each
  • Easy-Exs 12 × 16 in hinged access door, white plastic, open, with a water meter behind the opening

    Easy-Exs · PAD1216

    12x16 in Plastic Drywall Access Panel with Hinged Door

    Rated 4.4 out of 5, 2,789 ratings online

    Maximum service opening 10.35 × 14.35 in (estimated) · Overall 12 × 16 in

    USD $16.49 each

    • 10+ panels: $13.99 each
    • 80+ panels: $10.99 each
  • Easy-Exs 6 × 6 in hinged access door, white plastic, open, with a shut-off valve behind the opening

    Easy-Exs · PAD0606

    6x6 in Plastic Drywall Access Panel with Hinged Door

    Rated 4.4 out of 5, 2,789 ratings online

    Maximum service opening 4.35 × 4.35 in · Overall 6 × 6 in

    USD $8.49 each

    • 10+ panels: $7.49 each
    • 80+ panels: $6.49 each

The short answer

If your opening is in a fire-rated wall or ceiling, needs a lock, or is large, these makers' steel doors are the right kind of product, and the Easy-Exs range isn't. For a plain access point in residential drywall, their plastic doors and the Easy-Exs plastic doors and spring panels do the same job; the differences are in how each is sized and fixed.

The plastic doors, side by side

Karp HANystrom PL and Babcock-Davis BPLEasy-Exs PAD doors
Material1/8 in high-impact styrene1/8 in high-impact styrenePlastic, white gloss
Sizes4 × 6 to 22 × 22 in, plus 29 × 14 in4 × 6 to 22 × 22 in, plus 14 × 29 in6 × 6, 8 × 8, 12 × 12 and 12 × 16 in overall
Hole for the 8 × 8 in size8 × 8 in8 × 8 in (9-3/4 in overall)6.35 × 6.35 in cut-out for the 8 × 8 in PAD0808
How it opensPivot hinge with a snap friction catchRemovable door with snap latchesHinge and latch
How it is fixedGlued in with caulking adhesivePress-fit or set with adhesiveSet into its cut-out
Fire ratingNon-ratedNon-ratedNot fire-rated

Each maker's figures come from its own product pages, data sheets and shop drawings; Easy-Exs figures come from our product records. Where a maker's web page and documents differ, the table follows the data sheet: Nystrom's page and drawing disagree on whether the PL has a hinge, and Babcock-Davis's BPL page lists 6 × 9 to 14 × 29 in where its data sheet lists 4 × 6 to 22 × 22 in.

The steel drywall doors

  • Karp KDW. Flush drywall door with a 16 gauge steel frame and door, removable pin hinge, screwdriver latch or cylinder lock, from 6 × 6 to 36 × 24 in.
  • Nystrom NW and Babcock-Davis BNW. Architectural doors with a drywall bead, 16 gauge steel or stainless, from 6 × 6 to 36 × 36 in as standard, with a choice of latches and locks.
  • Elmdor DW series. Drywall doors in 16 gauge galvannealed steel with a concealed piano hinge and screwdriver latch, from 6 × 6 to 30 × 72 in.

These are the doors to look at for a commercial building, a lock, a large opening or a painted steel finish. Easy-Exs makes no steel door: every panel and door we sell is plastic.

Which one suits your job

  • A fire-rated wall or ceiling. A rated steel door from one of these makers. None of ours is rated.
  • A lock, or an opening above 14 × 14 in. Their steel doors come with lock options and in larger sizes.
  • A residential drywall access point. Their plastic doors or an Easy-Exs door or spring panel. The Easy-Exs range can be ordered online here in US or Canadian dollars, and every listing gives the opening it needs.

Sources

Checked November 15, 2026. Specifications change; the maker's current documents govern.

The brand and model names on this page belong to their owners. Buy Access Panels is not affiliated with or endorsed by Karp, Nystrom, Babcock-Davis or Elmdor, and does not sell their products.

Comparing brands?

Side-by-side notes on the access panel brands people search for, from each maker's published specifications:

All brand comparisons

Questions

Do Karp, Nystrom, Babcock-Davis or Elmdor make plastic access doors?

Three do. Karp makes the HA (Handi-Access), Nystrom the PL and Babcock-Davis the BPL, all 1/8 in high-impact styrene doors, non-rated, from 4 × 6 in up to 22 × 22 in plus a 14 × 29 in size. We found no plastic model on Elmdor's site.

Do these brands make fire-rated access doors?

Yes. Elmdor's FR series, for example, is listed with a UL 1-1/2 hour B label for walls, and Karp and Nystrom list rated doors too. None of the Easy-Exs panels or doors is fire-rated, so a rated wall or ceiling needs one of those.

What size hole does a Nystrom PL plastic door need?

Nystrom's shop drawing gives the rough opening as the nominal size, except the 12 × 12 in model at 11-13/16 in: an 8 × 8 in PL needs an 8 × 8 in hole and measures 9-3/4 in overall. The Easy-Exs PAD0808 is 8 × 8 in overall and needs a 6.35 × 6.35 in cut-out.

Are Nystrom and Babcock-Davis the same?

Their plastic doors share the same published specifications, and both companies' sites give the same street address in Minnesota. Neither site says how the two are related, so we don't state it.